These vegan chocolate peanut butter cookies are pools of chocolatey, peanut buttery goodness with layers of flavor and plenty of texture all packaged in lusciously soft delights!
It’s been a while since I baked cookies. I think it was around Christmas and I made ginger cranberry oatmeal cookies. In a home where even one day without them seems like eleventy-thousand years, that’s a really long time.
So, much to the appreciation of the people at home, Friday morning, I gathered the ingredients for vegan chocolate peanut butter cookies.
The combination had been in my head for some time because all of us are big, big fans of peanut butter and who here doesn’t love chocolate?
The cookies came out soft-baked and much like a brownie. Basically, deathly good. By the time I sat down to write this blog, only three were left. Wondering how many did I bake? 18!
How to Make Vegan Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies?
Vegan chocolate peanut butter cookies are rich, nutty, chocolaty delights that you can make in just half an hour! They bake to a creamy, fudgy consistency with the sweet/salty flavour of the peanut butter truly coming through.
In a bowl toss in the dry ingredients – all-purpose flour, baking soda, salt and cocoa powder – and set it aside.
In another bowl, add coconut sugar, peanut butter, coconut oil, milk, and vanilla extract. Beat the ingredients to get a creamy, fluffy mixture.
Make the dough by mixing the dry ingredients into the wet and then rolling it into small balls.
Flatten the tiny orbs slightly by using the tines of a fork and imparting that lovely signature criss-cross pattern to the chocolate peanut butter cookies.
The cookies are now ready for the oven!
I prefer vegan recipes, but you can easily bake non-vegan chocolate peanut butter cookies. Instead of coconut oil, use softened butter.
For the milk, you can use almond, coconut or regular milk. I had some homemade almond milk, so I used that.
For delicious, no-compromise gluten-free chocolate peanut butter cookies, use buckwheat flour. I’ve made cookies with it before, like the Lemon Buckwheat Linzer Cookies, and they come out deliciously buttery.
If you want to amp up the flavour of cookies, though they surprisingly don’t need it, use good cocoa powder. I feel when baking chocolate goods, you should go dark or go home.
By dark, I don’t mean the bittersweet taste. I mean the intensity. That’s why my chocolate peanut butter cookies came out dark, intense and wonderfully chocolaty.
The coconut oil has to be melted and then cooled before you pour it in.
Instead of coconut sugar, you can use brown sugar, raw sugar or even jaggery powder.
Baking the vegan chocolate peanut butter cookies
Truth be told the cookies are actually creamy peanut butter fudge masquerading as scrumptious chocolate cookies. The trick to getting that crackly exterior with a decadently tender center is not to over-bake them.
About 8 to 10 minutes should do it. I recommend keeping an eye from the eight-minute mark. If you leave them for too long, the cookies will get dry.
For me, 10 minutes was the perfect time to get that absolutely intense peanut butter savour that melts and coats the top of the palate with every mouthful of these gooey cookies!
Decorating the chocolate peanut butter cookies
Once the cookies are out of the oven and cooled (takes all of 5 minutes), you can pretty them up with some peanut butter glaze.
This is an entirely optional step, but it does add to the look of the otherwise dark cookies.
FYI, don’t judge the chocolate peanut butter cookies by their cover. The taste is phenomenal with or without the glaze.
To make the glaze, mix peanut butter with warm water and icing sugar. You can then drizzle the smooth, thick paste on the cookies using a spoon. I used a piping bag since there was one at hand.
Serving the chocolate peanut butter cookies
With the chocolate peanut butter cookies, I was gunning for soft cookies with a brownie-like thickness. Not at all cakey, but uber fudgy. Think soft, rich interiors you can sink your teeth into with a tall glass of cold milk or even a cup of coffee!
The recipe is easy. It is remarkably quick and makes about eighteen decent sized cookies. But even if it dictated that I blend 20 different types of ingredients while singing an aria, I would have done it.
The vegan chocolate peanut butter cookies are that good!
I’d love to hear from you! Please tag me on I’d love to hear from you! Please tag me on Instagram @tashasartisanfoods, using the hashtag #tashasartisanfoods. You can also FOLLOW ME on INSTAGRAM, PINTEREST for more fabulous recipes!